Method Comparison Fundamentals
Method comparison studies assess whether a new measurement method agrees with an established reference method. The goal is NOT to test correlation (which can be high even with systematic bias) but to assess agreement.
Key analyses:
• Passing-Bablok regression — non-parametric, robust to outliers
• Deming regression — parametric, accounts for error in both methods
• Bland-Altman plot — visualizes bias and limits of agreement
Common pitfalls:
• Using Pearson correlation alone (high r does not mean agreement)
• Using ordinary least squares (assumes X is error-free)
• Ignoring proportional vs constant bias distinction