Figure 11 in Revision of the Eocene 'Platyrhina' species from the Bolca Lagerst atte (Italy) reveals the first panray (Batomorphii: Zanobatidae) in the fossil record

Figure 11. Comparative strict consensus trees from parsimony analyses run in PAUP showing the hypothetic relationships of †Eoplatyrhina gen. nov. and †Plesiozanobatus gen. nov. (in bold) among batoids. A, consensus tree of total dataset with suprascapular coding according to Compagno (1999) and to Da Silva et al. (2018); B, consensus tree of total dataset with suprascapular coding according to Compagno (1999) and Da Silva et al. (2018) with the exclusion of character 85 and excluding Heterodontus + Squalus (-HS). Dashed line from Hexanchidae represents a polytomy recovered in CH, compared to DS. Grey inset indicates the section of the tree with most variability, as it relates to the position of Rajidae. Numbers above branches reflect the Bremer support. Closed circles = Torpediniformes; open circles = Platyrhindae; closed triangle = Zanobatidae; open triangle = Myliobatiformes + Zanobatidae; upside-down open triangle = Myliobatiformes; closed rectangles = Rajiformes; open rectangles = Sclerorhynchoidea; open diamond = Rhinopristiformes; open J = Jurassic batoids. See Table 1 for all tree statistics and see Supplemental material, File 1, Fig. S1 for all characters mapped in support of tree B.